Adblock adding ads to block ads

shutterstock_151488752Confused yet? The popular browser extension AdBlock for Chrome/Chromium and Safari has launched a new crowdsourced campaign – to buy up internet advertising space inviting people to download AdBlock, so they can block ads. Additionally, if they raise enough, they’d like to get additional space for a billboard at Times Square, a full page spread in the New York Times, and even a TV slot at the Superbowl (although the target for this is $4.2M, so I’m not entirely confident they’ll make it.)

However, this does raise an interesting question, which has been under debate for some time. How do you make money on the internet without adverts? Wikipedia has a few interesting suggestions.

Firstly, affiliate programmes. These mean that any products or services that are linked or searched via the original site earn a little bit of commission for that site. Founded in the mid-90s, and most famously used by Amazon, it’s a possible method for getting money. However, it should be deployed with careful thought. If a blogger or reviewer is recommending a product, is it simply because they are being paid to do so, or is it a genuine endorsement? The BBC ban this practice, and the Society of Professional Journalists also has strong guidelines on taking gifts. Interestingly, a few search engines now offer this to browsers for them sending their default search traffic to them.

Secondly, you could engage in (what I consider to be) the shady practice of data monetisation. People visit a website, and they leave data about their visit. By visiting here, you’ve told me that you’re probably interested in technology issues, what country and city you’re from, and where you came from. Other programmes and sites will also be able to wrap up what other sites you’ve visited, and can build up quite a profile of your browsing habits. Add together a rather unscrupulous vendor, and they can also know your contact details. This metadata can then be sold on.

Thirdly, you can essentially ask your readers for money. Donations, via a micropayment link (which I use) or larger donation requests. Another method is to have a membership system, where content is locked up behind a paywall. This does, however, risk making your content less valuable as people will just head elsewhere for news and opinion. To counter this, a couple of sites (LWN, Slashdot) simply delay the latest news for a little while. Alternatively, you can just ask like the fantastic C G P Grey has done. Interestingly, he also has a great video on why advertising can be a bad thing for content creators.

Lastly, you can sell things. This could be your authorship services on another site as a guest post, writing a book, offering consultancy services, or simple merchandise.

In summary though, which is more honest? An advert may well bend your view on what sort of content is being created, but is at least a lot more open than potentially hiding real motives behind affiliate links, and a lot more open than selling data. Asking for money is fairly straightforward, though could easily backfire if it’s viewed as begging. Google’s advertising income totalled $43.7 billion in 2012 – so it’s quite clear that advertising is big business. Websites cost money to run, can the web survive in an ad-free environment? If so, it certainly won’t be the same web as we know today.

Flattr this!

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. DDD says:

    Websites with adverts are like proprietary software. You can install an adblocker in the same way that you can pirate Windows. If you don’t like the model, you know what you have to do…

    • Neil McGovern says:

      Um… I *do* have Adblock installed, and I whitelist the sites that I want to support. I think you may be missing the point of the article though – what happens when advertising is no longer a method of supporting a site?

  2. Small typo in your post – “Alternatvely” should be “Alternatively” :)

  3. Robert says:

    Web advertising is one of those things I think where the economics is along the lines of “you don’t have to run faster than the bear, just faster than the next slowest person”.

    i.e. I won’t really encourage other people to block advertising (unless it’s really obnoxious) because I quite like getting my “free” stuff and I realize that it’s them who support it. But I do block ads myself to some extent.

    (on the subject of obnoxious advertising, these days I’m a big fan of pay-per-click advertising – knowing that my click is going to cost the obnoxious advertiser maybe ~$0.90 is priceless)

  4. phillip says:

    The hosts file from this website is updated about every month.

    “You can use a HOSTS file to block ads, banners, 3rd party Cookies, 3rd party page counters, web bugs, and even most hijackers.”

    Of course, Linux calls it “hosts”, not “HOSTS”.

    I use it and never see ads on YouTube, etc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.